Lukas Brandt
Research
Cooperation and Competition in Argumentative Teaching-Learning Processes. A Quasi-Experimental Video Study in Civic Education
Dissertation, successfully defended on 23 October 2026 at the Department of Social Sciences, TU Dortmund University. Publication in preparation.
Argumentation is central to political learning. It enables students to consider different perspectives, examine arguments critically and develop well-founded political judgments. It remains unclear, however, under which conditions discussion-based teaching methods foster the quality of argumentative learning processes and political judgment formation.
The dissertation examines how cooperative and competitive goal structures affect argumentative teaching and learning processes in civic education. It focuses on the quality of oral classroom discussions, on written argumentative judgment formation and on the relationship between the two.
The theoretical framework is a subject-specific opportunity-use model that links social interdependence theory and the concept of constructive controversy (Johnson, 2015) with the deep-structure perspective of classroom research. The cooperative or competitive goal structure is treated as a feature of the surface structure, whereas argumentative processing is examined at the level of the deep structure.
The study is a quasi-experimental video study in civic education classes at academic-track secondary schools (Gymnasien) in North Rhine-Westphalia. A total of 21 classes from grades 8 and 9 and the introductory phase of upper secondary school (EF) at seven schools took part (N = 516). Sixteen classes completed a seven-lesson teaching unit on the controversy over lowering the voting age to 16, which concluded with a fishbowl discussion framed either cooperatively or competitively. Thirteen discussions were video-recorded, twelve of which were included in the analyses of oral discourse.
In addition, questionnaires, content knowledge tests and students' written argumentative judgments were collected in a pre-post-follow-up design. The analysis combines quantitative analyses of oral argumentation processes with analyses of individual written judgment formation.
The data come from the research project “Politikkompetenz fördern: Eine Videostudie im Politikunterricht zu den Fachkonzepten ‘Wahlen’ und ‘Repräsentation’ anhand der Kontroverse um die Absenkung des Wahlalters auf 16 Jahre” (WahlViP) at the Professorship for Didactics of Social Sciences, TU Dortmund University.
References
Detjen, J., Massing, P., Richter, D. & Weißeno, G. (2012). Politikkompetenz – ein Modell. Springer VS.
Gronostay, D. (2019). Argumentative Lehr-Lern-Prozesse im Politikunterricht: Eine Videostudie. Springer VS.
Johnson, D. W. (2015). Constructive controversy: Theory, research, practice. Cambridge University Press.




